Newborn babies are most vulnerable to various insults in the first 28 days of life. Respiratory distress is one of the commonest disorders of newborn. It occurs among 4 - 7 % of all neonates [1, 2] and is the reason for 30 - 40 % of admissions in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). Respiratory distress is more common among preterm (30 %) and post-term (21 %) than among term neonates (4.2 %) 2. Neonates with respiratory distress have high chances of landing up in failure and are subjected to mechanical ventilation which is a kind of artificial ventilation and potentially
lifesaving. Survival rate in artificially ventilated neonates is reported as 64% by Trotman [3] and 67.9% by Karthikeyan and Hossain [4] though
survival of such neonates has been higher in developed countries [5]. This study was done to know the current scenario of our unit and thereby to
improve the ventilatory outcomes of neonates admitted in our newborn care unit.
Aim : To estimate the ventilatory outcome of neonates in terms of survival and mortality.
Objectives:
1. To estimate the ventilatory outcome of neonates in terms of survival rate.
2. To estimate the proportion of causes leading to the mechanical ventilation in our unit.
Methodology:
• Place of study: SNR District Hospital, Kolar , Karnataka , India.
• Period of study : August 2020 to July 2023
• Type of study: Retrospective descriptive study.
• Inclusion criteria:
1. Neonates with respiratory distress requiring invasive mechanical ventilation.
2. Neonates delivered by caesarian section or vaginal delivery.
• Exclusion criteria:
1. Neonates with respiratory distress requiring non invasive mechanical ventilation
2. Neonates with Congenital anomalies.
3. Post surgical babies
4. Neonates suspected with metabolic syndromes.
Method of collecting data:
Neonates with respiratory distress in respiratory failure admitted in our newborn care unit was assessed clinically for the need of invasive mechanical ventilation as per our unit protocols. The indications for initiation of invasive mechanical ventilation were: (i) PaO2 <50 mmHg, (ii)
PaCo2 >60 mmHg, (iii) intractable or recurrent apnea, (iv) gasping or poor respiration, (v) O2 saturation 60 mmHg despite CPAP pressure of 7–8 cm H2 O and FiO2 of 0.8 or recurrent episodes of apnea [6].The data regarding those babies requiring invasive mechanical ventilation was collected from our unit records and analysed.
During the period of our study 2084 neonates admitted in our neonatal unit, out of which 137 neonates required invasive mechanical ventilation
and satisfied our inclusive criteria. Among the 137 neonates , 75 (54.7 %) being male and 62 (45.3 %) being female neonates. The most common
cause requiring invasive mechanical ventilation in our study being Respiratory distress syndrome (51.8%) followed by perinatal asphyxia (
22.6%), meconium aspiration syndrome ( 13.9%) ,congenital pneumonia (8%), neonatal sepsis ( 1.5%), feed aspiration ( 1.5% ) and meningitis (
0.7% ) ( Table 1 )
Table 1 :Diagnosis of the neonates requiring invasive mechanical ventilation in the study
Neonates with gestational age of < 32 weeks are administered with surfactant therapy and initially started on CPAP therapy .Those neonates
that are not successful on cpap were ventilated. During the period of this study, 53.2% neonates were extubated successfully and discharged
and 46.8 % neonates were not survived. During the course of treatment complications recorded were neonatal sepsis,disseminated intravascular
coagulation, shock,pulmonary haemorrhage, intraventricular haemorrhage, pneumothorax, hypoglycemic episodes. Most common organism identified with neonatal sepsis among the ventilated neonates were Klebsiella followed by staphylococcus .Shock and pulmonary haemorrhage were significantly associated with the mortality of the neonates.
Among all the neonates in the study 71 babies diagnosed with RDS, 37 neonates ( 52.1% ) were survived and got discharged and 11( 57.9 % )
among 19 neonates diagnosed with meconium aspiration syndrome were survived ,17 ( 54.8 % ) among 31 neonates diagnosed with perinatal
asphyxia were extubated and discharged. 7 ( 63.6%) among 11 neonates diagnosed as pneumonia was extubated successfully.one neonate ( 50
% ) with feed aspiration and1 neonate ( 50 % ) with neonatal sepsis on mechanical ventilation was survived.
Table 2: Distribution of neonates requiring mechanical ventilation by weight
Table 3: Distribution of neonates requiring mechanical ventilation by gestational age
Various Indian studies report a survival rate of 40% to 60%. [7]. In this study, we attempted to determine the survival outcome of the neonates
on mechanical ventilation. The percentage of neonates admitted in our neonatal unit requiring mechanical ventilation during our study was
6.57% and predominantly male neonates ( 54.7 % ).The mean gestation age of the neonates in our study requiring mechanical ventilation being
35.825 ± 2 weeks with median gestational age being 37 weeks. Mean birth weight requiring mechanical ventilation being 2.05kg ± 915 grams. Most
of the neonates in our study were preterm ( 52.55 % ) .
Respiratory distress syndrome ( HMD ) was the most common indication of mechanical ventilation in our study similar to the studies done by Singh
M et al [6]., Iqbal Q et al [7]., Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8]., and Thakkar, Pareshkumar A. et al [9]. Perinatal asphyxia is the second most common
indication of mechanical ventilation in our study similar to the study done by Nangia S et al [10]., The highest survival rate in our study was congenital pneumonia (63.6 % ) followed by meconium aspiration syndrome (57.9 % ) and perinatal asphyxia ( 54.8 % ).
Of the all neonates in our study 79 ( 57.7 % ) neonates developed complications. 41 (51.89 % ) neonates developed sepsis , which was the
most common complication in our study similar to the study done by Singh M et al [6],.16 ( 20.25 % ) neonates developed shock ,12 ( 15.18%
) neonates developed pulmonary haemorrhage which was most common complication in premature neonates in our study. In this study, mortality
in ventilated neonates was 46.8%, which is comparable to mortality of 43% reported by Iqbal Q et al [7]., Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8].,and Thakkar,
Pareshkumar A. et al [9]., reported figures of 43.3% and 52%, respectively. whereas in the studies done by Hossain et al [11]., and mathur et al [12]., mortality rate was very high which was 70.6 % and 74% respectively.
Table 4 : Comparison of survival rates of neonates on mechanical ventilation in various studies
The survival rate in the neonates with RDS in our study was 52.1% which was almost similar to the studies done by Iqbal Q et al [7] and Das, Bijoy
Kumar et al [8] whereas the survival rate in the study done by Hossain et al [11] was less than our study. Survival rates of neonates on mechanical
ventilation depends on availability of surfactant especially for preterm neonates and facility for parenteral nutrition and strict protocols for sepsis control in the neonatal units which differs significantly among the developed and developing countries. Neonates with meconium aspiration
syndrome has better survival outcome on mechanical ventilation in the studies done by Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8] and Iqbal Q et al [7] than
the outcome seen in our study whereas survival outcome with similar indication in the study by Hossain et al [11] was less than our study .
In contrast to our findings, the studies by Hossain et al [11]., and Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8]., found lower survival outcomes with identical indications in their studies on neonates with perinatal asphyxia, whereas the study by Iqbal Q et al [7]., found better survival outcomes on mechanical ventilation.
The survival rate of neonates with pneumonia on mechanical ventilation was 80% in Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8].’s study, which was higher than
ours, and 100% in the study conducted by Hossain et al [11]. In addition, compared to Hossain et al [11]. and Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8]., our study
included a larger study sample and most of the neonates with pneumonia are outborn where most of the damage happened out of our unit .
In neonates with sepsis, we saw similar survival rate i.e., 50% seen in the study done by Das, Bijoy Kumar et al [8]., and as well as better outcomes than the studies done done by Hossain et al [11] and Iqbal Q et al [7] .Drugresistant bacteria are becoming more common, and certain neonatal unit antibiograms exhibit inconsistent patterns in different studies. These changes have a substantial impact on the outcomes of sepsis-affected newborns on mechanical ventilation.
The survival outcome of neonates on invasive mechanical ventilation in our study was 53.2 % .The most common indication of invasive mechanical
ventilation in our study being Respiratory distress syndrome followed by Perinatal asphyxia .Neonatal mechanical ventilation can have a better
survival outcome when provided with timely availability of surfactant and parenteral nutrition facilities by strengthening the neonatal units in rural
public sector hospitals.
Limitations
Those neonates who received exclusively CPAP or noninvasive ventilation was not the focus of our study. Apart from that we were unable to study
the variables that affect morbidity, like length of hospital stay, mechanical ventilation, and NICU stay.
Financial support and sponsorship Nil.
There are no conflicts of interest.
[1] Misra PK. Respiratory distress in newborn. A prospective study. Indian Pediatr 1987;24(1):77-80.
[2] Kumar A, Bhat BV. Epidemiology of respiratory distress of newborns. Indian J Pediatr 1996;63(1):93-8.
[3] Trotman H. The neonatal intensive care unit at the University Hospital of the West Indies: The first few years’ experience. West Indian Med J2006;55:75-9.
[4] Karthikeyan G, Hossain MM. Conventional ventilation in neonates: Experience from Saudi Arabia. Indian J Pediatr 2002;69:15-8.
[5] Richardson DK, Gray JE, Gortmaker SL, Goldmann DA, Pursley DM, McCormick MC. Declining severity adjusted mortality: Evidence
[6] Singh M, Deorari AK, Paul VK, Mittal M, Shanker S, Munshi U, Jain Y. Three-year experience with neonatal ventilation from a tertiary care hospital in Delhi. Indian Pediatr. 1993 Jun;30(6):783-9. PMID: 8132260.
[7] Iqbal Q, Younus MM, Ahmed A, Ahmad I, Iqbal J, Charoo BA, Ali SW. Neonatal mechanical ventilation: Indications and outcome.Indian J Crit Care Med. 2015 Sep;19(9):523-7. doi: 10.4103/0972-5229.164800. PMID: 26430338; PMCID: PMC4578196.
[8] Das, Bijoy Kumar et al. “Immediate Outcome of Mechanically Ventilated Neonate : One Year Experience in Neonatal Intensive Care Unit of Combined Military Hospital Dhaka.” (2022).
[9] Thakkar, Pareshkumar A. et al. “Clinical Profile, Outcome and Risk Factors for Mortality of Neonates Requiring Mechanical Ventilation at Tertiary Care Centre of Central Gujarat, India.” Journal of Nepal Paediatric Society 41 (2021): 29-34.
[10] Nangia S, Saili A, Dutta AK, Gaurvani MS, Kumari S. Neonatal mechanical Ventilation. Experience at a level II care Centre. Indian J Pediatr. 1998; 65: 291-296
[11] Hossain MM, Mahfuza S, Abdullah MA, Hassan MN, Sahidullah M.Predictors of mortality in ventilated neonates in intensive care unit. Bangladesh J Child Health. 2009;33:77–82. 12. Mathur NB, Garg P, Mishra TK. Predictors of fatality in neonates requiring mechanical ventilation. Indian pediatrics. 2005 Jul 1;42(7):645.
IJBMR -ISSN: 0976:6685. ©Copyright 2026 This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Published by BioMedSciDirect Publications