Patient safety is a cornerstone of healthcare quality, including clinical laboratory services. Clinical Biochemistry is a discipline of medicine that functions toprovide diagnostic tests that physicians utilize to assess an individual's health. An important form of clinical laboratory service concerned with patient safety is the result of critical values. A critical value is defined as “a laboratory test result that represents a pathophysiologic state at such variance with normal as to be life-threatening unless something is done promptly and for which some corrective action could be taken” [1].
Critical values are potentially life-threatening laboratory results that need to be communicated immediately to the doctor or other healthcare provider so that therapeutic measures can be instituted rapidly. Instant communication of these critical values leads to faster diagnostic processes and a rapid change in patient management. Clinical laboratories must establish optimal critical value limits to achieve a balance between informing clinical staff and overloading them with results that do not require urgent action [2,3,4].
The importance of clinical laboratories is currently acknowledged in the medical world; around 70% of decisions taken arebased on laboratory investigations [5]. One of the most important functions of a clinical laboratory is the clear, precise, and quick communication of a critical value to health care providers [6]. Critical or panic values were first described by Lundberg as “potentially life-threatening test results unless necessary treatment is done promptly in clinical laboratories” [1, 7].
Critical/Panic values are the values that lie outside the normal range to a degree that may constitute an immediate health risk to the individual or require immediate action on the part of the ordering physician. Over the 30 years since Lundberg’s observations, many laboratories have embraced the concept of establishing crucial values and reporting systems[7]. Critical values must be proactively identified and reported timely and accurately to support effective clinical decision?making based on the test results[9,10]. The effectiveness of clinical laboratory critical values notifications will directly be related to the safety of patients and affect the satisfaction of customers with laboratory service [8].
Reporting critical values continues to receive widespread attention from healthcare givers, as it symbolizes a crucial clinic-laboratory link. This is because healthcare providers eventually realized the importance of prompt and timely communication of the critical results, which have positive implications on patient safety and treatment outcomes. In addition to physicians and nurses, patients are also recipients of critical values, where they can make informed decisions prior to clinical intervention [12]. Also, it is pertinent to say that the result of critical values is an important form of clinical laboratory service concerned with patient safety [12]. It is necessary to develop a laboratory management system that reports these critical values and can reduce the mortality rate. Many clinical laboratories have prepared and used their quality procedures for defining critical values, their limits, reporting time, and documentation process [13, 15].
Communicating critical values is an important issue; however, present guidelines do not identify who should be responsible for receiving them; head physician, registered nurse, attending physician, or some other health care provider. This notification should be registered, as well as a confirmation that the caregiver has accepted responsibility for follow-up. Thus, the aforementioned critical value notification procedure of clinical laboratories must be carefully considered, as it affects patient safety and quality of clinical care [16]. Various reporting systems have gradually developed for effective notification including phone calls, online reporting and text messages, however all having some limitations [4, 17].
The aim of our study was to evaluate the current situation in our laboratory concerning notifying critical values, in order to detect our strengths and weaknesses, which would enable us to improve the whole process and develop a reliable method for identifying critical reports at the earliest. This would further enhance fast reporting of accurate critical values with a minimum post analytical (TAT) for better patient care.
The prospective study was conducted in the Clinical Laboratory of the Department of Biochemistry of GB Pant Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education & Research (GIPMER), a 780-bed super specialty hospital in New Delhi. The study was designed to identify areas of laboratory practice that could be improved in order to reduce the TAT of critical value reporting. The duration of the study was fromJunetoAugust 2023.
The Quantitative data of tests with critical values was collected and analyzed in this study tocomprehensively address the research statement. Samples received in the Biochemistry lab,GIPMER are run on Cobas C-501(Roche diagnostics), a fully automated analyzer. There is a preset limit for every analyte, if the value of a particular analyte comes out of this limit, then the sample undergoes auto-verification and the value is reconfirmed. A new critical alert modality was introduced in July 2023 which included flagging of results in a critical range. The time of the sample received in our laboratory was duly noted to calculate a precise TAT.
Evaluation of turnaround time (TAT)
For this evaluation, TAT was defined as the time interval between the specimens received in the laboratory to the time of reports dispatched with verification. Samples are sorted, numbered and the time of receiving samples in the laboratory is noted. Followed by sample centrifugation and analysison the auto-analyser. In June the evaluation of TAT was not properly monitored. The sample receiving time was also not noted properly. The receiving time for samples received between 9 am to 11 am was taken as 9.30 am and the majority of them were reported after 3 pm after verification. Therefore, for convenience turnaround time for all critical reports in June was taken as 6 hours (360 minutes). In August, receiving time was properly noted and all critical values were properly documented after verification and finally reported via telephone. The time of informing the report was noted down. TAT was calculated for each sample throughthe difference between these timings; time of receiving the sample and time of communicating the report.
Critical value list
Laboratory test items to be notified with critical values were selected by the laboratory director in discussion with the clinicians who use laboratory services, referring to relevant literature [30]. In the present study, the existing system of critical value reporting was monitored for a period of one month. The data for the study was collected from all critical values obtained from the emergency department (ED) and inpatient department (IPD). The existing system of critical values reporting was documented and analyzed for June 2023. The following are the included critical values for clinical chemistry (Table 1).
Table 1: List of critical values
|
Sr. no. |
Analyte |
Low critical value |
High critical value |
|
1 |
Serum Sodium |
<120 mEq/L |
<160 mEq/L |
|
2 |
Serum Potassium |
<2.8 mEq/L |
<6.2 mEq/L |
|
3 |
Serum Magnesium |
<1.0 mEq/L |
<4.7 mEq/L |
|
4 |
Plasma Glucose |
<40 mg/dL |
>450 mg/dL |
|
5 |
Blood Urea |
>240 mg/dL |
- |
|
6 |
Serum Creatinine |
- |
>5.0 mg/dL |
|
7 |
Creatinine Kinase (Total) |
- |
>1000 U/L |
|
8 |
Serum Amylase |
- |
>200 U/L |
|
9 |
Serum Lipase |
>700 U/L |
- |
|
10 |
Amino transferases (AST, ALT) |
- |
>1000 U/L |
To improve the efficiency and effectiveness of critical value notifications, a quality control circle (QCC) was formed, which included the laboratory director, resident doctors, laboratory technicians, and nursing in-charges from all wards. An intervention plan was implemented to improve reporting processes, incorporating four quality improvement strategies derived from the QCC, starting in July 2023; (1) Establishing a critical value notification policy:In June 2023, the turnaround time (TAT) and procedure for critical value reporting were evaluated and reviewed to develop an updated policy. (2) Training technical staff:Training sessions were conducted in July 2023 to emphasize the importance of critical values and the need to reduce TAT. These sessions were held in batches over one month to ensure coverage of all technicians across all shifts. (3) Optimizing the notification system:A pop-up alert system was introduced to notify technicians immediately when critical values were generated. (4) Implementing a quality indicator:A TAT-based quality indicator was established to monitor and evaluate the entire critical value notification process.
Design of laboratory critical value notification system and its implementation
Before implementing theintervention plan, critical values were observed during reporting, verified, and subsequently communicated to the respective staff or doctor on duty (DOD). This process took an average of 6 hours (360 minutes).
To enhance efficiency, critical value thresholds were established for each analyte in the analyzer's test menu. Additionally, a critical alert notification feature was integrated into the autoanalyzer's software. This upgrade ensured that whenever a measured value exceeded the set critical limits, the analyzer displayed a flashing flag with a color change and a pop-up window on the screen, prompting the technician to address the critical value promptly.
Once identified, the critical value was verified, which involved rechecking the sample and repeating the test if necessary. After approval by the laboratory DOD, the critical value was promptly communicated to the respective clinician, resident doctor, or nursing staff telephonically.Laboratory personnel delivering the report were instructed to request a read-back verification of the critical value. The recipient—whether a physician, designated professional, or nurse—repeated the information back for confirmation. The name of the staff or doctor receiving the report, the patient's diagnosis, and the reporting time were documented both in the requisition form and ina separate register by the laboratory personnel (Figure 1).
Observational checklist
The parameters,procedure of critical value identification and reporting shall be recorded. Points included in different criteria for compliance of critical value reporting were; name of patient, name of investigation, date of investigation, reported by, time of report generation, time of report informed and reported to.
During this observational study, we aimed to analyze delayed notifications. Therefore, all critical values were considered as separate events. Result generation time and reporting time for each critical value were recorded separately and delayed tests and delayed reporting times were evaluated daily.
Statistical analyses were performed using statistical software (SPSS for Windows, version 21.0, Chicago, IL, USA). Critical value, delayed reporting frequencies, and their percentages were calculated.The statistical difference was determined by the Mann-Whitney test. If p < 0.05, the result was accepted as statistically significant.
Figure 1: The flowchart of laboratory critical values notification
In June 2023, total 80595 biochemistry parameters tests were reported, among which 141 (0.17%) reports were critical. Out of these 141 critical reports, 108 were notified (76.6%). This was in June, when the study started and no interventions were introduced. Post-intervention; software updation and imparting training to technical staff in July, data was collected for the month of August. It was observed that out of 85918 total test parameters reported to ward and emergency department, 165 were found to be critical alert values and 100% of all 165 were reported on the phone as soon as identified. (Table 2) The patients' reports from OPD were not included in the study.
Table 2: Critical Values obtained pre-intervention(June) and post-intervention(August)
|
|
Total tests done |
Critical values obtained |
Critical values reported |
Percent of Critical values reported (%) |
|
June |
80595 |
141 |
108 |
76.6 |
|
August |
85918 |
165 |
165 |
100 |
The median TAT in June 2023 for non-critical routine reports in the intervention period was 480 minutes and that of critical reports was 360 minutes. Similarly, in August 2023 median TAT for non-critical values was 480 minutes and for critical values it was 90 minutes (Table 3). The results clearly demonstrated a substantial and statistically significant difference in TAT between the two months. The difference between the critical values between the two months was statistically significant with a p-value<0.0001.
Table 3: Turnaround time of critical reports obtained pre-intervention and post-intervention
|
|
June (Median TAT) |
August (Median TAT) |
|
Non critical reports |
8 hours |
8 hours |
|
Critical reports |
6 hours |
1.5 hours |
The highest TAT reported in August was 105 minutes and earliest value reported was within 15 minutes. The Interquartile Range (IQR) is a measure of statistical dispersion that describes the spread or variability of data within a dataset. It provides valuable information about the middle 50% of the data, excluding the lowest and highest values. A larger IQR suggests greater variability within the dataset, while a smaller IQR indicates less variability. The IQR for June was from 360 to 360. This implies that the middle 50% of the TAT data for June is concentrated in a very narrow range from 360 to 360. A narrow IQR, as observed in June, indicate virtually no variability within the TAT values for that month. In this case, all data points in the middle 50% of the dataset are essentially the same, with an IQR of zero. The IQR for August is from 60 to 80. This means that the middle 50% of the TAT data falls within the range of 60 to 80. A relatively wide IQR, as seen in August, suggested moderate variability in the TAT values for that month. In other words, the TAT values in August are spread out over a range of 20 units between the 25th percentile (Q1) and the 75th percentile (Q3) (Table 4).
Table 4: Interquartile Range (IQR) for critical reports obtained pre-intervention and post-intervention
|
Month |
June’23 |
August’23 |
|
Sample size |
108 |
165 |
|
Lowest TAT (mints) |
360 |
15 |
|
Highest TAT (mints) |
360 |
105 |
|
Median |
360 |
75 |
|
Interquartile range |
360 to 360 |
60 to 80 |
As depicted in figure 2, median TAT of non-critical was same for both pre and post intervention state. Whereas it was significantly reduced from 6 hours to 1.5 hours in critical reports (figure2). Of the total critical values analysed in June 23 and August 23, 234 were from ward patients (77%).
Figure 2: Comparison of turnaround time of critical and non-critical values in June and August.
Critical value reporting can be defined as the time needed for laboratory staff to validate and communicate with the attending doctor treating the patients. A critical value is most often a numerical determination of a physiologic abnormality. The numerical value may be determined to be abnormal by variance from a mean value and is related to evidence-based risk to a patient's likelihood of poor outcome unless clinical intervention is given priority [28]. Each month the reporting time is evaluated based on the results of the division between the numerator and denominator. The numerator is the number of patients with reported critical value results, while the denominator is the total number of patients with critical value results. The target is 100%.The reporting of critical values plays an important role as a part of the quality indicators of the laboratory. Therefore, critical results of laboratory examinations are documented in medical records of the patients. In our laboratory, the staff who reports the critical value results, record the reports in a well-maintained register.
In several studies, laboratories have used different alerting (visual or audible) and reporting systems such as phone calls, online reporting, and text messages to prevent delays in critical value reporting [4,18]. Nevertheless, phone call is still the most common method used in clinical laboratories because of their ease of use for asking all recipients to read back the critical values [19,20]. In a study, Piva et al. recommended an alternative reporting system ensuring read-back procedure. They used software that generates automated notification by a specific text message sent to the cell phone of the responsible healthcare personnel [21].
The laboratory accrediting agencies have made critical value reporting, a part of the requirements for accreditation [22,23] Furthermore, the immediate notification of a critical value as a special requisite has been recognised and implemented worldwide through the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 15189:2012, and has been adopted as a standard of Good Laboratory Practice (GLP)[24,25] Critical value reporting thus became an accreditation requirement, with most laboratories having implemented critical value policies as a quality assurance practice. A growing number of publications have addressed the reporting of critical values [21,26-28].
A CAP?sponsored study of 121 institutions determined that it takes a total of 7 minutes for a technician to notify clinicians about a critical result once testing is complete [29]. Laboratory professionals are often challenged with many hindrances in the reporting of critical values, including establishing clinically relevant criteria for critical values, resolving difficulties in finding the doctor who ordered the report when a critical value is obtained, and confirming that the doctor understands the severity and implications of a critical result [30].Critical value reporting is a medically important issue and its procedure varies between the laboratories and hospitals.
This study was undertaken to examine and evaluate the reporting of critical laboratory values to the treating doctors based on the existing Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) of the clinical Laboratory of Biochemistry, GIPMER. Of all the parameters, it was observed that in our laboratory the top parameters which were most frequently witnessed in list of critical alerts were electrolytes – sodium and potassium. Apart from these - urea, creatinine, AST, ALT, and bilirubin were also frequently reported. Other parameters reported were glucose, magnesium, CK Total (creatinine kinase), lipase and amylase. Laboratory results classified as critical value in our laboratory were analyzed for a period of one month; in the month of June 2023. The TAT for these critical values was evaluated. This was done for the samples received from IPD and the emergency department only. OPD was exempted from the study.
It was observed that critical values were noticed only when samples collected in the laboratory were processed and then sent for verification to doctor on duty (DOD). Critical results of laboratory examinations were observed and verified by the resident doctor in charge when all the reports were received by doctors for reporting after analysis. Then they all were collected and reported telephonically to respective wards by the laboratory staff at one time after analysis. Although these reports were informed on phone and not just sent to wards with other routine reports, still there was a big delay in reporting of critical values. The averages TAT for these reports at that time were 6 hours and only 76.6% of total critical reports were notified on phone. After reviewing the TAT of critical reports, an intervention was planned and changes were incorporated in the system to improve the reporting and reducing the average TAT of the critical values. Certain modifications were done in the software of the auto analyzer in consultation with the application engineer. The critical values were added in the application procedure of the parameters in such a way that if results lied in critical ranges, machine would give critical alert flag with the report.
There after training of all the technical staff was scheduled and four such sessions were undertaken to cover all the technicians, during their postings in shift duties on a rotation basis. This training was held in month of July 2023. Technicians were taught about the importance of critical values and significance of its timely reporting to the treating doctor. After this exercise it was observed that critical values were being reported as soon as they were flashed on the screen of the auto analyzer. Immediate action is taken and results are notified on telephone towards after signing and verifying with resident doctor posted in laboratory. This was followed by reviewing the outcome to see improvement in critical value reporting. The achievement of critical values improved after the flag system was implemented. The average TAT post intervention was significantly reduced to 1.5 hours and 100% critical reports were reported telephonically as compared to 76.6% in the month of June 2023. It was observed that after the training and timely flagging of critical reports, not only did TAT reduced but also documentation improved. The critical value flag system was useful for increasing a fast and accurate reporting and also able to reduce mortality, as an effort to improve patient safety. The flag system implemented in our laboratory has markedly improved critical reporting and can be used as a best practice for other laboratories to implement. We have developed an effective time to report critical values and to maintain this it is recommended that evaluation of Critical Value must be carried out every 6 months.
Reporting of critical alert values is an important requirement as well as important phase of the clinical laboratory testing process. If the criteria for critical value reporting are not adequately matched, it indicates the futility of the process. The final aim should be that these values must be communicated to treating doctors immediately to improve the final outcome of the patients. In conclusion, each laboratory should determine their critical value reporting policy according to their needs and facilities. However, there is a need for developing more effective technologies supporting phone call and decreasing workload of nursing staffs to maximize clinical benefits.
None
[1] Lundberg GD. When to Panic over Abnormal Values. Med Lab Observer. 1972; 4:47–54
[2] Dighe AS, Rao A, Coakley AB, Lewandrowski KB. Analysis of laboratory critical value reporting at a large academic medical center. Am J Clin Pathol. 2006; 125:758–64. 10.1309/R53XVC2U5CH6TNG8
[3] Plebani M, Sciacovelli L, Aita A. Quality Indicators for the Total Testing Process. Clin Lab Med. 2017;37:187–205. 10.1016/j.cll.2016.09.015
[4] Piva E, Sciacovelli L, Zaninotto M, Laposata M, Plebani M. Evaluation of effectiveness of a computerized notification system for reporting critical values. Am J Clin Pathol. 2009; 131:432–41. 10.1309/AJCPYS80BUCBXTUH
[5] Rocha, Bruna Claudia B et al. The critical value concept in clinical laboratory. J.Bras.Patol.Med.Lab.2016;52:17- 20.
[6] Genzen JR, Tormey CA. Pathology consultation on reporting of critical values. Am J Clin Pathol.2011;135(4):505-13.
[7] Lundberg GD. Critical (panic) value notification: an established laboratory practice policy (parameter). J Am Med Assoc 1990;263:709.
[8] White GH, Campbell CA, Horvath AR. Is this a critical, panic, alarm, urgent, or markedly abnormal result? Clin Chem.2014;60(12):1569?1570. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
[9] Hortin GL, Csako G. Critical values, panic values, or alert values. Am J Clin Pathol. 1998;109(4):496?498.
[10] Kawthar AlSadah 1, Omar S El-Masry 1, Faisal Alzahrani 1, Amer Alomar 1, Magdy Abdel Ghany. Reporting Clinical Laboratory Critical Values: A Focus on the Recommendations of The American College of Pathologists. J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad.2019 Oct-Dec;31(4):612-618.
[11] Rosita L, Edy P. Performance of Laboratory Critical Value on Clinical Laboratory Services in Supporting Patient Safety. Advances in Health Sciences Research, volume 33
[12] Kost GJ. Critical limits for urgent clinician notification at US medical centers. J Am Med Assoc 1990;263:704–7.
[13] Kost GJ. Critical limits for emergency clinician notification at United States children’s hospitals. Pediatrics 1991;88:597–603.
[14] Tillman J, Barth JH, ACB National Audit Group. A survey of laboratory ‘critical (alert) limits’ in the UK. Ann Clin Biochem 2003;40:181–4.
[15] Don-Wauchope AC, Chetty VT. Laboratory defined critical value limits: how do hospital physicians perceive laboratory based critical values? Clin Biochem. 2009;42:766–70. 10.1016/j.clinbiochem.2009.02.016
[16] Kuperman GJ, Teich JM, Tanasijevic MJ, Ma’Luf N, Rittenberg E, Jha A, et al. Improving response to critical laboratory results with automation: results of a randomized controlled trial. J Am Med Inform Assoc 1999;6:512–22.
[17] Carroll AE, Saluja S, Tarczy-Hornoch P. Development of a personal digital assistant (PDA) based client/server NICU patient data and charting system. Proc Am Med Inform Assoc Symp 2001;100–4.
[18] Howanitz PJ, Steindel SJ, Heard NV. Laboratory critical values policies and procedures a college of american pathologists Q-probes study in 623 institutions. ArchPathol Lab Med 2002; 126:663–9.
[19] Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations. International Patient Safety Goals 2007. Available at: http://www.jointcommission.org/PatientSafety/NationalPatientSafetyGoals. Accessed January 8th 2018.
[20] Piva E, Pelloso M, Penello L, Plebani M. Laboratory critical values: automated notification supports effective clinicaldecision making. Clin Biochem. 2014;47(13–14):1163?1168.
[21] College of American Pathologists. Laboratory Accreditation checklist. Available at: http://www.cap.org/apps/cap.portal. Accessed January 18th 2018.
[22] Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations. International Patient Safety Goals 2007. Available at: http://www.jointcommission.org/PatientSafety/NationalPatientSafetyGoals. Accessed January 8th 2018.International Organization for Standardization (ISO). ISO 15189:2012. Medical laboratories – particular requirements for quality and competence. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization; 2012. [Google Scholar]
[23] International Organization for Standardization (ISO). ISO 15189:2012. Medical laboratories – particular requirements for quality and competence. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization; 2012. [Google Scholar]
[24] Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI). Management of Critical- and Significant-Risk Result. CLSI guideline GP47 1st Edition. Wayne, PA: Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute; 2015.
[25] Duan F, Liao J, Lin L, Liu X, Wu K. Prevalence of laboratory critical results in eye patients from an eye hospital insouthern China. Biomed Res Int. 2017;2017:8920350. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
[26] Wu SW, Chen T, Xuan Y, et al. Using plan?do?check?act circulation to improve the management of panic value in thehospital. Chin Med J (Engl). 2015;128(18):2535?2538.
[27] Onyenekwu CP, Hudson CL, Zemlin AE, Erasmus RT. The impact of repeat?testing of common chemistry analytes atcritical concentrations. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2014;52(12):1739?1745. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
[28] Kost GJ, Hale KN. Global trends in critical values practices and their harmonization. Clin Chem Lab Med. 2011;49(2):167?176.
[29] Bhatia K, Bhatia P, Udari SN, Patil N. Study on laboratory critical value analysis in a multi-speciality hospital. MedPulse International Journal of Biochemistry. October 2019; 12(1): 06-09.
[30] Emancipator K. Critical values: ASCP practice parameter. Am J Clin Pathol. 1997;108(3):247?253.
IJBMR -ISSN: 0976:6685. ©Copyright 2026 This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Published by BioMedSciDirect Publications