Background: Incisional hernia is a common postoperative complication occurring in 10–25% of patients following laparotomy. Mesh repair is the accepted standard of care; however, the optimal plane of mesh placement—onlay or sublay—remains debated. This study aims to systematically compare outcomes of onlay and sublay polypropylene mesh repair for ventral incisional hernia. Methods: An observational prospective study was conducted at KIMS, Karad, over 24 months. Twenty-six patients with ventral incisional hernia (13 per group) underwent either onlay or sublay polypropylene mesh repair. Outcomes including surgical site infection (SSI), seroma formation, early recurrence (within 3 months), postoperative pain (Day 1), and hospital stay were assessed and compared using Chi-square test (SPSS v28, p < 0.05 significant). Results: Sublay repair showed significantly lower SSI (0% vs 38.5%; p = 0.018), seroma formation (7.7% vs 46.2%; p = 0.032), and early recurrence (0% vs 30.8%; p = 0.041) compared to onlay repair. Postoperative pain on Day 1 was significantly milder in the sublay group (p = 0.021), and hospital stay outcomes were better (p = 0.039). Age, gender, hernia size, and operative duration were comparable between groups. Conclusion: Sublay polypropylene mesh repair is superior to onlay repair in terms of fewer postoperative complications, reduced early recurrence, lesser pain, and improved hospital stay outcomes. Sublay repair should be the preferred technique for elective ventral incisional hernia surgery.