Facial dermatoses often pose diagnostic challenges due to their overlapping clinical features and diverse etiologies. Relying solely on morphology may lead to misdiagnosis, inappropriate treatment, and delayed recovery. This case series describes eight patients who presented with morphologically similar facial plaques but were diagnosed histopathologically to have distinct conditions, including discoid lupus erythematosus, subcutaneous mycosis, cutaneous leishmaniasis, granuloma faciale, lupus vulgaris, borderline tuberculoid leprosy, squamous cell carcinoma, and erythematotelangiectatic rosacea. Most lesions involved the central face, with a right-sided predominance. Early biopsy and histopathological confirmation can help prevent inappropriate therapies, ensure targeted treatment, and reduce the psychosocial burden associated with disfiguring facial dermatoses and their complications.